Printable · GCSE Foundation · ages 14-16
Identities, equivalence and algebraic proof worksheet — GCSE Foundation
Fifteen questions on "identities, equivalence and algebraic proof" — DfE statement A6. Print it, or print three versions so neighbours cannot copy by letter; the key gives the letter for each version.
part HigherNon-calculator
Answer key: Identities, equivalence and algebraic proof worksheet — GCSE Foundation
MathsUKwww.geekhero.co.uk
- (b) It is not even an ordinary equation with a solution: expanding the left-hand side gives 3x − 12, and 3x − 12 = 3x − 4 would require −12 = −4, which is never true. — Expanding the left-hand side, 3(x − 4) = 3x − 12. Setting this equal to the right-hand side, 3x − 12 = 3x − 4, gives −12 = −4 once the 3x terms are removed from both sides — a statement that is never true, so no value of x satisfies the equation at all, and it is certainly not an identity. The option about substituting a specific value misunderstands algebraic expansion, which holds for every x, not one chosen value. The option matching the first term wrongly assumes that is enough to prove equivalence. The option about multiplying the 4 by 3 on both sides is nonsensical, since there is only one bracket to expand, on the left-hand side.
- (a) 2(3x + 1) = 6x + 2 — Expanding 2(3x + 1) = 6x + 2 gives an expression that matches the right-hand side exactly for every value of x — it is an identity. 4x − 3 = 3x + 5 is an ordinary equation with one solution, x = 8. 7 − x = x − 7 is also an ordinary equation with one solution, x = 7. 5x + 1 = 5(x + 1) never holds for any value of x at all, since expanding the right-hand side gives 5x + 5, and 5x + 1 = 5x + 5 would require 1 = 5, which is impossible.
- (b) 2(x + 3) = 2x + 6 — An identity is true for every value of x, not just one. Expanding 2(x + 3) gives 2x + 6, which matches the right-hand side exactly — so the equation holds for every value of x, and it is an identity. Each of the other three is only true for one particular value of x: 5x − 3 = 12 gives x = 3, x + 7 = 15 gives x = 8, and 3x = x + 10 gives x = 5 — these are ordinary equations, not identities.
- (c) Only x = 5 satisfies 3x + 5 = 20, not every value of x. — 3x + 5 = 20 is only true when x = 5, since 3 × 5 + 5 = 20; for any other value of x the two sides are not equal, so it is an equation, not an identity. Saying it cannot be simplified confuses simplifying with the equation/identity distinction, which is about how many values of x make it true. Saying it has an = sign is not a valid test, since identities are also written with an = or ≡ sign. A number on the right-hand side does not decide it either — what matters is whether both sides match for every value of x, not the form of the right-hand side.
- (c) x + 18 — Expand −3(2x − 6) by multiplying both terms by −3: −3 × 2x = −6x and −3 × (−6) = 18, giving 7x − 6x + 18 = x + 18. Writing x − 18 comes from not flipping the sign of the −6 inside the bracket, so −3 × (−6) is treated as −18 instead of +18. Writing x + 6 comes from forgetting to multiply the −6 by 3, only carrying its sign. Writing 13x − 18 comes from treating the whole bracket as being added rather than subtracted, so 3(2x − 6) = 6x − 18 is added to 7x.
- (d) 4x + 5 — A minus sign directly before a bracket changes the sign of both terms inside it: 6x − (2x − 5) = 6x − 2x + 5 = 4x + 5. The option 4x − 5 comes from only changing the sign of the 2x term and not the −5, giving 6x − 2x − 5. The option 8x − 5 comes from adding 2x instead of subtracting it, as if the minus sign did not apply to the bracket, giving 6x + 2x − 5. The option 8x + 5 repeats that same addition mistake and also changes the sign of the −5 term.
- (c) 4x − 3 — Subtract each term inside the bracket: 5x − (x + 3) = 5x − x − 3 = 4x − 3. Writing 4x + 3 comes from subtracting the x but not the 3, keeping its sign positive. Writing 6x − 3 comes from adding the x term, 5x + x = 6x, instead of subtracting it. Writing 5x − 3 comes from ignoring the x term inside the bracket and only subtracting the 3.
- (a) 4(x + 3) = 20 and 4x + 3 = 11 when x = 2, so the two expressions are not equivalent, because the bracket means the 3 must be added before multiplying by 4. — Substituting x = 2: 4(x + 3) = 4 × 5 = 20, and 4x + 3 = 8 + 3 = 11. The two values are different, and expanding 4(x + 3) algebraically gives 4x + 12, which can never equal 4x + 3 (that would require 12 = 3) — so the two expressions are never equivalent, for any value of x. The option claiming they become equal for a larger x is wrong: 4x + 12 = 4x + 3 has no solution at all. The option claiming they are equivalent because they share the terms 4x and 3 ignores that the bracket changes the constant term. The option that calculates 4(x + 3) as 11 ignores the bracket completely, applying the 4 only to the x term.
- (c) 2x + 12 — Multiply every term inside the bracket by 2: 2 × x = 2x and 2 × 6 = 12, so 2(x + 6) = 2x + 12. Writing 2x + 6 comes from multiplying only the x-term and leaving the 6 unchanged. Writing x + 12 comes from multiplying only the 6 and leaving the x unchanged. Writing 2x + 8 comes from adding 2 and 6 instead of multiplying them.
- (c) 10x − 15 — Expand the bracket first: 3(2x − 5) = 6x − 15. Then add the 4x: 6x − 15 + 4x = 10x − 15. The option 10x − 5 comes from forgetting to multiply the 5 inside the bracket by 3 (treating it as 6x − 5), then adding 4x. The option 10x + 15 comes from a sign error when expanding, treating 3 × (−5) as +15 instead of −15, then adding 4x. The option 6x − 15 comes from expanding the bracket correctly but forgetting to add the 4x term at all.
- (d) Yes, since expanding 6(x − 1) gives 6x − 6. — Expand the bracket: 6(x − 1) = 6 × x − 6 × 1 = 6x − 6, which matches the second expression exactly, so the student is correct for every value of x. Saying 6(x − 1) means 6x − 1 comes from multiplying only the x and forgetting to multiply the 1 by 6. Saying brackets always change an expression's value is not true — expanding here gives back an equivalent expression, not a different one. The identity holds for every value of x, not just whole numbers, since both sides are expanded algebraically, not tested by substitution.
- (c) The 5 must multiply both terms inside the bracket, so 5(x + 2) expands to 5x + 10, which is never equal to 5x + 2 for any value of x. — Expanding the bracket correctly, 5(x + 2) = 5x + 10, since the 5 multiplies both the x and the 2. This is never equal to 5x + 2, since that would require 10 = 2. The option claiming 5(x + 2) means 5 × x + 2 ignores that the 5 must multiply the whole bracket, not just the x-term. The option about working out the bracket first with a value of x misunderstands algebraic expansion, which holds for every x, not just specific ones. The option about addition before multiplication misapplies the order of operations to bracket expansion, which always distributes the outer factor over every term inside, whatever x is.
- (c) x = 0 — Expand (x + 4)² correctly: (x + 4)² = x² + 8x + 16. This equals x² + 16 only when 8x is zero, i.e. when x = 0 — at every other value of x the two expressions differ by 8x. Choosing x = 4 confuses the constant inside the bracket with the value of x that makes the expressions match. Choosing x = −4 makes the same confusion but with the sign flipped. Choosing x = 8 mistakes the coefficient of the middle term, 8x, for the value of x itself.
- (d) Formula A gives £39 and Formula B gives £39, and since 3(2n + 5) expands to 6n + 15 for every value of n, the stallholder is correct. — Formula A: 3(2 × 4 + 5) = 3 × 13 = £39. Formula B: 6 × 4 + 15 = 24 + 15 = £39. Expanding Formula A algebraically gives 3(2n + 5) = 6n + 15, which is identical to Formula B for every value of n, not just n = 4, so the stallholder is correct — this is an identity, not a coincidence. The option giving £29 for Formula A comes from multiplying only the 2n by 3 and forgetting to also multiply the 5, then adding the unmultiplied 5: 3 × 2 × 4 = 24, + 5 = 29. The two options that reach the correct numbers but reject the stallholder's claim both use faulty reasoning — matching values at one value of n, or counting terms, does not decide whether two expressions are identical for every n; expanding the bracket does.
- (a) x + 14 — Expand each bracket separately: 3(x + 4) = 3x + 12, and −2(x − 1) = −2x + 2 (multiply −2 by both x and −1). Combine: 3x + 12 − 2x + 2 = x + 14. Writing x + 10 comes from taking −2(x − 1) as −2x − 2, not flipping the sign of the −1 inside the bracket. Writing 5x + 10 comes from treating the second bracket as +2(x − 1) instead of subtracting it, so the x-terms are added rather than subtracted. Writing x + 13 comes from only multiplying the 2 by the x, and carrying the −1 across unmultiplied.
Build your own mix at the worksheet builder.